“Through our hands on review process, Top Pick Leads is able to viably select the best providers based on the results of actual use and implementation of the leads…”

As an insurance agent I’m sure you know all too well the daunting task of trying to find quality insurance sales leads online. Just do a quick search of the keyword “insurance leads” on Google, there are about 133 million results as of this post.  There are a lot of lead providers online that claim to be the best in the market.

So as an agent, what are you supposed to do? You could spend thousands of dollars testing each provider, not to mention countless hours.  You could also ask your colleagues who they think is best. But if you are not partnered together they may not give you the best options.

TopPickLeads.com is a free service that was designed by a group of insurance agents to help other insurance agents find quality internet insurance sales leads.

We have done this by purchasing test batches of various insurance leads from 20 of the top internet insurance lead program providers. We narrowed that to a list of 4 providers that we consider the best of the best.

Stop torturing yourself – Top Pick Leads is here to help

Through our testing, extensive research and reviews we have compiled a list of who we believe are the TOP insurance lead providers in the industry today. We have tested each of these providers first-hand and have found them to have provided us with the best quality insurance leads at the most competitive price. So what are you waiting for? Stop torturing yourself testing lead companies that fall short of your expectation.

The main focus of Top Pick Leads is return on investment (ROI). Since ROI is the most important aspect of insurance sales leads, the rest of our criteria insures that you get more conversions to sales and written policies. Top Pick Leads knows that you need the freshest and most current leads available, so we strive to provide exactly that.

Top Pick Leads – Lead accuracy and freshness

With a hands on approach, Top Pick Leads is able to select the best providers based on the results of actual use and implementation of the leads. Lead accuracy and freshness are among the most vital of the characteristics of a quality insurance sales leads package. All contact info, names and locations are verified for accuracy. Most, if not all, leads provided should not be more than 2 days (48 hours) old, so you have the first contact with those prospects. So we leave lead providers off that provide leads that are more than 48 hours old.

We also know that you should be able to filter those leads by any criteria you deem important. Whether by demographic, location, age state or gender, all the leads you get are the most relevant to what you need. Other factors that are also important are lead price and deliverability are important as well, so we make sure you get the best quality leads for your money and that they are delivered in real time as soon as possible. This is true whether you take electronic delivery (email) or a CD via US mail or postal service.

In addition to all these reviews and tests, Top Pick Leads also takes into consideration the company history AND the level of customer service provided. Top Pick Leads makes sure that every lead is backed by a company that is trustworthy and has a proven track record. We do all this to remove the guesswork and speculation. Every order is as good as the last: guaranteed.

All these things add up to the one thing that really matters: your return on investment (ROI). Insurance sales leads are only as good as the data they include, so they have to be fresh, they have to be accurate and they absolutely MUST be backed up by a reputable company. We do all of this for you to make certain that you write more policies and talk to more prospects than any of your competition. In that area, Top Pick Leads gives you the edge.

Below is a list of who we believe are the best insurance lead program providers online today. You can even try their leads for free. They all offer many different insurance lead types, such as Life Insurance Leads, Health Insurance Leads, Auto Insurance Leads, Annuity Leads and many more.

Our "Top Pick" Lead Providers

Get quality leads for virtually any market or demographic.



1st Place


  • Targeted, high-quality search generated leads.
  • Large selection of lead types and lead filters.
  • Get 30% off of first lead type


2nd Place


  • Over 700 advanced demographic filters...
  • No long-term contracts or subscriptions.
  • Get 50% off of second lead type


3rd Place


  • CALL (855) 625-3644 TODAY!
  • A+ with the Better Business Bureau.
  • Special discount offer when you sign up...


4th Place


  • Real-time, high-converting leads.
  • No contracts or minimum orders
  • 50% off of weekend leads

Learn How We Rate Lead Providers

We have tested hundreds of lead sources to find YOU the highest-quality leads possible.

  • Lead Accuracy

    Lead Accuracy

    We have tested and verified all of our Top Pick providers for information accuracy.

  • Lead Freshness

    Lead Freshness

    Our Top Pick providers delivery only the freshest, most recent leads available.

  • Lead Filtering

    Lead Filtering

    Our Top Pick providers give you maximum control over demographics and qualifiers.

  • Lead Price

    Lead Price

    Our Top Pick lead sources are extremely competitive and surprisingly affordable.

  • Real-Time Deliverability

    Real-Time Deliverability

    Our Top Pick providers can deliver leads to you in real-time as they become available.

  • Company History

    Company History

    Our Top Pick providers are all carefully vetted based on trustworthiness and reliability.

  • Lead ROI

    Lead ROI

    Obviously, you want to generate maximum return on your lead acquisition investment.

  • Service


    When you need support, clear communication is essential. Our Top Picks deliver the best support.

  • Lead Cost

    Lead Cost

    Our providers offer affordable, flexible plans for every budget with no long-term contracts.

  • "I have been using two of the Top Pick online insurance leads providers you recommended and could not be happier with leads I am getting. I’m writing more business now than I have in years!"
    Andre Villegas
    - San Diego, CA
  • "Just wanted to drop in and say thank you for the insight, your website saved me a lot of time and money by doing all the leg work for me by researching all of the best insurance leads providers. Thanks again."
    Marissa Jonston
    - Ft Myers, FL
  • "Both the quantity and the quality of leads that I'm able to get and close are beyond compare. I can't even consider this 'cold calling' because I know everything about my lead before we connect."
    Mark Hanson
    - New York, NY
  • "TopPickLeads.com saves you time and money. If you're an agent and are considering purchasing Internet insurance leads and not using them, you are making a huge mistake."
    Mark Toleson
    - Miami, FL
  • "WOW is all I can say! I am very happy I found your website. My lead closing ratio is now at 10%, and they way things look I think I can get it to 20% with all of the appointments I have now."
    Grace Steward
    - Sparta, TN
  • "I have used TopPickLeads.com for auto insurance leads and have been very happy. Their lead sources are spot-on. When you have leads like these, your life becomes a lot easier. Thank you."
    Jennifer Riley
    - Cincinnati, OH
  • "Hello, just wanted to let you know I got the info and signed up with 2 of your suggested providers for auto insurance leads and got $200 in free auto leads with on and a huge discount with the other."
    Brian Barrett
    - Hamilton, CA
  • “Just wanted to drop in and say thanks for the provider picks, insight, and reviews. Your site saved me a lot of time and leg work for me and confirmed a lot of my own research."
    Donna McKenzie
    - Washington, DC
  • "Excellent information and reviews. You really can't go wrong with your "top picks". I have been using all of them for several years now and can swear by them. No fear of agent competition either!"
    Michael Barille
    - Des Moines, IA
  • TopPickLeads.com has been the best for final expense leads for us and great for getting the proper profiles that my agency requires. This has led to solid production and retention."
    Denise Wallace
    - Metairie, LA
  • "Your services has worked out great!! I am writing almost one out of every two Final Expense leads I get from InsuranceLeads.com, if not every single lead! Thank you so much!"
    Marry Geraldos
    - San Francisco, CA
  • "This is a place to get started on your quest for leads if you are just getting started. I've tried dozens of providers and your TOP PICK LIST is absolutely the best. Glad I'm right as always 🙂 "
    David Spaun
    - Middletown, OH
  • "The life insurance leads from your top picks have been top notch. They are fresh, accurate, and laser-targeted. I can pick up the phone and close about 10% of the time which is EXCELLENT!!"
    Monica Sawyers
    - Ithaca, NY
  • "I have been receiving mortgage life insurance leads from InsureMe for just over a week now and sor far I am very satisfied. I currently have more leads working than ever before."
    Michelle Abel
    - Truth or Consequences, MX
  • "Hey Guys. Thanks for helping me find quality mortgage life insurance leads. I am really impressed with your service. As newbie, you pointed me in the right direction."
    Joseph Trailes
    - Boston, MA
  • "I have tried NUMEROUS other lead sources and have been dissapointed with all of them... If only I had found your website sooner I could have saved myself a lot of time, frustration and money."
    Mike Baker
    - Clarksville, TN
  • "In my 22 yrs in the insurance industry I've got to say that InsuranceLeads.com is the best health insurance leads provider I have used. I'm sure glad I found them through your website."
    Joseph Cambria
    - West Hollywood, CA
  • "Yours site is best business insurance lead sources of any site I have ever seen. It just take a minute of your time and you don't have to read on forever to get the facts. My hat is off to you."
    Christopher Jordan
    - Ft. Meyers, FL
  • "If you are currently purchasing Annuity leads and not using InsuranceLeads.com you are making a big mistake. The leads I have received are by far the highest quality in the industry."
    Steven Biggs
    - Seattle, WA
  • My closing ratio is substantially higher with the leads I have acquired through TopPickLeads.com than through any other party or service. That says a lot about the lead quality and freshness."
    Ed Walsh
    - Coshocton, OH
  • "Tried all of your recommended providers and got my free leads. Closed my first three. Working on the others. Yes, I can confidently say I am going to keep getting my leads from your top list."
    Danny Speers
    - Salt Lake City, UT

Post a Comment

Your email is kept private. Required fields are marked *

Got a question?

Connected with operator.

Click ENTER to chat

Close More Leads, Faster...

Get the knowledge you need to acquire and close unlimited leads quickly and easy. Our free Lead Closing Guide gives you everything you need to succeed immediately.